Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Honestly flabbergasted by your reply. How did she bait anyone? How did she set herself up to be victimized? People could have just… not been violent. That would have been an entirely plausible outcome, yet here we are.


“She shouldn’t have been wearing those kinds of clothes if she didn’t want that to happen.”


Thank you for this comment, I had a hard time pinpointing exactly what made me feel uneasy about all those answers justifying the audience behavior or explaining that they were setup for violence because various harmful objects were present.

It is indeed the same way of thinking.

If you murder someone, I don't see how you could blame them for being too close to a knife or gun. Having the opportunity to do something does not systematically justify doing it.

edit: this logic does not apply even if the person brought the harmful object with them, the decision to do the harm is ultimately not made by the victim.



Ah yes, the infamous city of Naples, where people have been intrinsically violent and bad people for decades, because .. Naples.


As Italian, with half of the family from Naples area, yes, that one.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: