Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

interesting project, for fun yes, but it seems it's based on an outdated assumption that 'thoughts are determined by language' [1] a sort of buy-one-get-one free.

However, human languages haven't been widely adopted with much success when designed/created top-down. Even more advanced and well developed languages such as Esperanto, haven't take off, though more widely adopted.

Personally I agree with Prof Steven Pinker, that Language is an Instinct, and that it evolves in communities, in stages, such as 'pidgin -> creole -> first/native language', most importantly developed & fortified by children.

The human brain has capacity for storing, processing and remembering tens of thousands of words, example [2]:

- 13K words for an average 3-year-old

- 60K words on average by the time they graduate from high-school

- a 3-year-old is likely to remember a new word casually mentioned in a conversation for up to 5 weeks

you may save in storage at the expense of processing, orchestrating, learning, and rather crucially accessibility. Except for fun, it's kinda pointless otherwise.

[1] Sapir-Whorf hypothesis of linguistic determinism "that people's thoughts are determined by the categories made avail- able by their language, and its weaker version, linguistic relativity, stating that differences among languages cause differences in the thoughts of their speakers".

[2] Language Instinct, Steven Pinker



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: