Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It appears that Pinterest is violating the Amazon Affiliates operating agreement.

https://affiliate-program.amazon.com/gp/associates/agreement...

Specifically:

  “Prohibited Paid Search Placement” means an advertisement
  that you purchased through bidding on keywords, search
  terms, or other identifiers (including Proprietary Terms)
  or other participation in keyword auctions. “Proprietary
  Term” means keywords, search terms, or other identifiers
  that include the word “amazon,” “endless,” “Kindle,”
  “smallparts,” “myhabit,” or “Javari,” or any other
  trademark of Amazon or its affiliates ( see a non-
  exhaustive list of our trademarks), or variations or 
  misspellings of any of those words (e.g., “ammazon,” 
  “amaozn,” “endlss,” “enldess,” “smalparts,” “kindel,” and
  “javary”). “Redirecting Link” means a link that sends
  users indirectly to the Amazon Site via an intermediate
  site or webpage and without requiring the user to click on 
  a link or take some other affirmative action on that
  intermediate site or webpage. “Search Engine” means Google, 
  Yahoo, Bing, or any other search engine, portal, sponsored 
  advertising service, or other search or referral service, 
  or any site that participates in any of their respective 
  networks.
Pinterest falls under both "Redirecting Link" and "Search Engine" parts of this clause.

In addition:

Section 10 requires affiliates sites to state they are an affilliate:

  You must, however, clearly state the following on your
  site: “[Insert your name] is a participant in the Amazon
  Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising 
  program designed to provide a means for sites to earn 
  advertising fees by advertising and linking to [insert the
  applicable site name (amazon.com, endless.com, 
  smallparts.com or myhabit.com)].”


You're totally off base on the first part.

1) Prohibited paid search placement: This only applies to bidding on placement on search engines. Pinterest has not bid on terms on their own site, so that section has no relevance even if Pinterest itself could be considered a search engine.

2) Redirecting links: This prohibits placing links that point to an intermediate page that then redirects to Amazon. Pinterest is linking directly to Amazon (with affiliate identifiers in the query string), not to an intermediate page that performs any redirection.


Any idea what the "redirecting links" clause means for URL shorteners and other redirect-based services?


I think it has to be taken in the context of paid search placement. You can't arbitrage/hide the traffic source(and the keyword for paid search) from amazon through redirection.


Depends on if they have a business agreement with Amazon that excludes them from those terms. At their size, they very well might.

Same way large AdSense customers are treated completely different and have their own contracts with Google.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: