Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more CountdownGraph's commentslogin

Did you ever engage a lawyer to review your option documentation?


While I agree generally w/ this advice, in my experience, companies try to make that impossible or very difficult for employees. For example, most hiring offers are exploding: I've been given exploding offers over a weekend, over holidays: try getting a lawyer when you're not at home. Further, again in my experience, getting a lawyer is actually significantly challenging to someone who hasn't done it: you need a lawyer in the relevant area of law, and you need to know their price, and these two critical pieces of information seem generally to be the things left off the website.

You can argue that an employee should try to negotiate for adequate time, and maybe they should, but not all will. Those too timid to do so are effectively being taken advantage of; thus I find most companies' positions morally reprehensible.


Does no-one see the irony in patenting an anti-piracy standard? If it is remotely effective, it will, itself, be pirated. If it is not effective, it will only make the lives worse of people who choose not to circumvent it.

Additionally, I just do not see how this passes subject-matter standards post Alice.[1] Seriously disappointing to see vague algorithms of this type receive patent protection.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alice_Corp._v._CLS_Bank_Intern...


This is one of my pet peeves with movies as well.

When I buy a DVD, I have unskippable trailers and an ad that warns me not to pirate it at the beginning. Seriously, it's about 10 minutes of crap that I need to watch to see the movie I f*ing paid for! The viewing experience with pirated movies is much more enjoyable and streamlined. I get the movie, double click on it and booom - it starts right away.


I mean, I've torrented every single DvD I own and the disks sit in the attic. Strangely, not once I have missed the lack of "hilarious cut scenes" or "Directors commentary" features.

Man I love clicking on a folder, scrolling for 30 secs and pressing play and the actual film just starts playing. The only thing that it fails on is remembering where I am in a series. So for eg. Blackadder I'd rather just stick on Netflix thank play in VLC


> The only thing that it fails on is remembering where I am in a series. So for eg. Blackadder I'd rather just stick on Netflix thank play in VLC

You can easily solve that one with something like Plex :-)


Can you install Plex in a standalone fashion, or do you need to set up a server and client?

With Kodi it'd just be a case of install and point it at your media directories.


If you don't mind using a web client (and you shouldn't, it's pretty good), you can install the Plex server on your machine and then open the web client on the same machine.


Upvote for Plex. Setting up a Plex box in my house was astonishingly easy and we now use that more than Netflix.


I had been hearing about Plex for a while and when I bought a Seagate Personal Cloud drive, I decided to give it a try.

I like it. I have moved a lot of media to it and I can watch it all at my convenience from multiple devices or computers in my house.

I have young children and after they destroyed several of the kid-movie DVDs I gave them, this was a godsend.


I've noticed Plex has stopped working with my TVs. It's kinda a bummer that the only help, that those on forums are willing to give is "buy a better TV". Is spending another 700 bucks really a tenable solution?


It's not a great solution, but there are several "streaming sticks" like the Roku, Chromecast, or FireTV for less than $50 you can buy and plug into your current TV.


Apple TV Gen 4 has a Plex app that works extremely well. Still $130 to put down but you also get all the other things it does.


Yep, only issue I have is that I now forget my netflix series because when I go to plex, my progress with those series isn't tracked or shown.


plus if you I guess do want to pirate, sonarr and radarr are freaking amazing to have a long with a plex server.


Install mpv and use Shift+Q to exit. That way when you open the folder again in mpv it will start exactly where you left it.


I just keep a little document in the same directory.

    echo 9 > last-episode
    mpv s01e09.mkv


If you're using mpv, do this instead:

mpv tvshow/season1

Now use Shift+Q to exit. The next time you run mpv tvshow/season1, it will resume from where you left.


Thanks for the tip!


The original "Barbershop" DVD had over 25 minutes of non-skippable previews and ads on it... So much so, that when the DVD player started skipping 5 minutes in (scratches on netflix rental), I never got around to watching it later (or asking for a different disc).

That's when I started ripping DVD content, just so I could watch it as the studios had gone way too far.


Yes. Thank you, Microsoft, for stifling the anti-pirating industry.

By the way, pirating seems to be in the interest of big non-content companies like Microsoft, Apple and Google.

The iPod became big because of pirating (what teenager can afford 64GB of music in the first place?), and this also holds for YouTube.

EDIT: fixed iPad -> iPod


Do you mean iPod? I never saw the iPad as a 'music listening device', but I never really used one though :-)


Not ironic. Just very fitting. They're using a failed system (patents) to try to monopolise their (probably very obvious) method of enforcing a failed monopoly system.


> But 35 percent of the company has been quietly controlled by an attorney at one of Apple's own go-to law firms, Morgan, Lewis & Bockius

In case no one here is aware, this firm has also been in other headlines recently:

> Lawyers who said Trump has no ties to Russia named Russian law firm of 2016

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/may/12/law-firm-rus...

Edit inb4 comments: I am not making any judgments of this firm, or implying that these things are in any way related. Additionally, as pointed out, this story is from 2013 and has been settled. It is interesting, however, to see this old story popping up now.


I am using postgres and redis - they are both trivial to set up and cost about a few lattes a month for a fairly scalable solution. If I had huge traffic, a few hundred bucks a month would be totally adequate - and this is running on the too-expensive heroku. So, unless Riak costs pennies and takes literal minutes to set up, the 10x claim won't hold.

Riak looks like it would be overpowered by my needs - but then again, I learn something new every day.


Yeah. It is like a spelling error in an essay about spelling.

Not great.


>The quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog.

That was bugging the heck out of me.


Author here. And to think of it that I wrote it over two days. Two days. Made a couple of my friends read it. I am embarrassed and will fix it by tonight.


No worries!!

Also, don't let all the very tough feedback on here get you down. Tough crowd on here!


I will not . I am just truly grateful that some people took the time out to read something I wrote. Amazing !!


fixed.


Yes, there is a theoretical limit for temperature.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Absolute_hot

For all intents and purposes, however, it is preposterously enormous.


That's not a limit for how hot temperature can get, just a limit at which existing theories break down.


No, there's not. Read what you posted more carefully. Planck temperature is the scale at which gravitation becomes as important as other forces, and thus without a working theory of quantum gravity we can't predict what happens at that scale.


IP Lawyer here. Note: I am a lawyer, but I am not your lawyer.

Upon using your name in commerce you acquire common law trademark rights. Filing a trademark before you are actually using it in commerce requires filing an Intent To Use trademark application and will cost you a few thousand dollars in legal fees (or a hell of a lot more if you are doing international) - either that or you are doing it yourself with trademarkia, and, in that case, I wish you bon chance.

Try to choose a strong name, but be prepared to change it.

"Strong" means, in order: a completely made up word, a word that has nothing to do with the product being offered, a word that is suggestive but not decriptive of the product. For more information, look up the "abercrombie" test. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abercrombie_%26_Fitch_Co._v._H.... http://berryentertainmentlaw.com/the-abercrombie-formulation...

If you want to search for competing marks, please note that this is an extremely technical process. You can try to search on TESS, but it is very difficult. https://tess2.uspto.gov

Note that this is only US trademarks.

Additionally, if your question is "how do I know if my mark will be infringing?" The answer is "that is an extremely hard and expensive question to answer." The touchstone of trademark infringement is the "likelihood of consumer confusion test," which is ensconced in the sleekcraft / polaroid factors. http://www3.ce9.uscourts.gov/jury-instructions/node/244 http://likelytocauseconfusion.com/likelihoodofconfusionfacto...

The point of all the above is that you really do need to be a professional at this in order to have the wherewithal to make judgments about the likelihood of a trademark's success. In addition, it takes a few business quarters to a year and a half for a registration to issue.

The point of all this is that domai.nr is as important a tool as TESS, that you can easily get lost in the weeds on this issue, that your own judgment is in no way a replacement or a substitute for a licensed attorney, that trademark strategy is hugely complicated and can be a total sinkhole. What does that mean? It means that, for a startup, like many, many other issues, you do the best you can but keep in mind that you are going to have to spend a lot of time and effort on it down the road.

Tl:dr: As a startup in general: IF YOU HAVE THE MONEY, it is worth starting this process this sooner rather than later. If you do NOT have the money, a reasonable strategy is to move forward with a name that you like but are willing to change. It is okay to change your name very early on. However, the goal is to avoid having to change your name when you already have a product out and some market presence. For YC: Do you need a trademark before you apply to YC? Almost definitely not - unless you are already selling your product. Do you need a trademark before you start selling your service to enterprises or spending money on marketing? It would be foolish not to at least engage an attorney and start the process.

Note that many other IP attorneys may have different opinions. That's fine - reasonable minds can differ on this subject, the above is an extremely short primer. Also please note that I AM NOT YOUR ATTORNEY AND IF YOU ARE THINKING ABOUT FILING A TRADEMARK YOU NEED AN ATTORNEY.

Edit: shoutout to https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=27182818284 for posting this PG blog post - extremely on point: http://www.paulgraham.com/name.html


Thanks for the intel. I love the disclaimer. Don't worry, I won't try to claim you :) My business is running under the current name, so i'm going to make it a goal to start the trademark app process via the USPTO sight by the end of the year. I don't have enough money to hire a lawyer as yet. I'm hoping to get into YC so that I can take care of this then. It's a unique name and I already own the domain and have a website running. This is all new to me, so I appreciate your intel.


Thank you for having the confidence to post and informed opinion from a lawyer perspective.*

I certainly appreciate the input.

*I recognize you are not acting as this person's lawyer :-)


Yeah I genuinely don't understand the point here. Who is protecting what?


So the article mentions the threat of retaliation against the security researcher, and you are surprised people are afraid to come out publicly?


I read more in the article so I am updating my comment - the FBI's involvement is surprising and alarming.

When in doubt, people, call your attorney.


Who just has an attorney sitting around who is competent to handle such things? I wouldn't know who the fuck to call if I found something on my bank's website.


I am one such attorney.


Can I get your number?


My sn is my name. I am the only lawyer named Liberty that I am aware of.

More easily, my profile on my firm's website: lawyernamedliberty.com. I'm fairly easy to get in touch with.


> Survivorship bias is "Zuck did X, Y and Z, if I do the same then I'll be a multi-billionaire too!"

This is also called "cargo cult behavior." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult#Metaphorical_uses_o...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: